Lindsey Pavao (Season 2)
A lot of previous contestants on The Voice took songs and really revamped them to make them their own, but Lindsey Pavao took that concept to a whole new level when she sang a beautiful rendition of “Say Ahh” — yes, that song. It took everyone a few seconds to realize what she was singing, and when they did, it was amazing. Lindsey was hands down one of the most unique artists on the show, and turned 3 chairs, ultimately winding up on Team Christina. In the end, Lindsey went home before making it into the top 4, and it broke my heart. You can still keep up with her on Twitter, though.